This is where I get nervous. Putting one of my desert island book choices out on the interweb for many and various to digest, discuss and dissect, hopefully not dismantle, deconstruct and destroy. But I am here to defend if the worst should happen and for now, to answer the questions I sent out to all readalong participants last week. And that feels weird too! Nonetheless, here I go ….
Q1: Welcome to the 1st German Literature Month Readalong! Had you heard of Theodor Fontane and Effi Briest before now? What enticed you to readalong with us?
Effi Briest was a German A-level set text so I first read her when I was 18 – 35 years ago. Heavens, how did that happen? I’ve reread Fontane’s masterpiece 3 times since then and it’s the German novel I have no hesitation in recommending to everyone. Hence this choice for a readalong. Besides there’s no justice in a world where Emma Bovary and Anna Karenina are more (in)famous.
Q2: Which edition/translation are you using and how is it reading?
I’m not reading in the original German although I still have my Ullstein German edition, which is now slightly foxed with damp patches and a slightly musty smell. It was damaged in a flash flood the day before I left Germany for Scotland. (Let’s not talk about omens of the wet weather I’ve experienced since then!) While I had to throw out many other volumes, I managed, with the aid of a hairdryer, to salvage Effi. (Yes, we’re on first names terms …..)
But I digress – this time round I am reading the lovely black Penguins classics edition, translated by Helen Chambers and Hugh Rorrison. It’s reading well,. Not as a modern novel but preserving the mood and style of a C19th novel.
Q3: Is the novel living up to your expectations?
How can it not? This read, my 5th, will tie Effi as the most reread novel of my life. (On a par with To Kill A Mockingbird.)
Q4: What do you make of Effi Briest and Baron von Innstetten. What motivates them? What do you make of their
match?
I can remember exactly how I reacted when I first read Effi. I was only a few months older than she at the time. And nowhere near as childish. I’d certainly given up swings. But then I was a child of the C20th, not the C19th. The word duty didn’t figure in my vocabulary. But Effi, a child of nature, adventurous and a little bit wild, does understand what is expected of her and is trying / will try so hard to conform to the expectations of her time and society. And while Innstetten is 21 years older than her, he’s a man in his prime. 38 isn’t decrepit, is it?
Baron von Innstetten is a Prussian public servant, a man of principle. And he’s still carrying a flame for his old love, Effi’s mother. She’s well and truly off-bounds. So, if he can’t have the mother, he’ll settle for the daughter, who’s still young enough to mould into his ideal wife. Or so he thinks.
As for the match, at the time it is made, there may be misgivings but there’s no reason to doubt that Effi and Innstetten won’t be able to find their way to a mutual understanding and a marriage based on affection, if not passion.
Q5: How are you reacting to Effi’s parents?
Now that’s a biggie (and it gets bigger as the novel continues). I’m quite fond of Effi’s dad, who I think understands what’s going on but finds life “just too big a question” to face head on. I know quite a few older men whose modus operandi is to avoid any unpleasantness. Effi’s mother, on the other hand, knows exactly what’s she’s doing. She’s handing her daughter to an ex-flame and living vicariously through her. Though there’s no malice. Geert von Innstetten is a good man with excellent prospects. Still quite a catch. Yet, she knows her daughter’s nature and you have to wonder why she’s in such a rush to marry Effi off. Like everyone in the novel, she’s a product of her time.
Q6: Are there any secondary characters to whom you are particularly drawn? Any to whom you are adverse?
How can I not love Rollo? Or Gieshubler, the hunchback who takes Effi under his wing and ensures she doesn’t feel abandoned when Innstetten is too busy making his career.
It’s difficult to condemn anyone in this novel. Fontane was a very understanding author. As in real life, all his characters have good and bad points. So there are no obvious bad guys. Although I do not like Marietta Tripelli – a social butterfly, whose influence on Effi is very unsettling.
Q7: Effi Briest was originally serialised in 6 parts. I’m assuming that its 36 chapters were published in 6 monthly parts of 6 chapters each and the novel so far seems to bear this out. How does the mood of the first part (chapters 1-6) contrast with that of the second (chapters 7-12)?
The mood darkens from the moment Effi steps over the threshold of her marital home: the eerie hall with its dead animals, the unfurnished first storey and the ghostly noise from the long swishing curtains. The uncanny nature of the Chinaman. Most unfathomable to me is the reluctance of Innstetten and the maid Johanna to accommodate Effi’s fears. Effi is still “half a child at this point” and the adults really should know better.
Q8: We finished our first reading at the end of chapter 15 or the middle of part 3. Where is Effi in terms of her psychological development and how does this bode for the future?
Effi is now 19 and a mother. A woman. In the final scene, Innstetten finds her seductive but he’s not comfortable with it. Enter Crampas ……
Other posts: Tony’s Reading List, Andrew Blackman, Mar gheall ar a léim, Beauty is a Sleeping Cat, IrisonBooks, A Work In Progress, Everybookhasasoul
This is my first time (and I’m coming to the end of the second of the three parts), and I am loving it so far. Interesting to hear about the parents as they really haven’t featured much up to now 🙂
I was wondering how they did translate “Die ist ein zu weites Feld”. “This is too big a question”, it seems. Hmmm.
I do not like that mother, as a matter of fact, re-reading the novel, I have two people I really do not like and that’s the mother and Instetten. Awful man. Condescending and full of himself.
Rollo… I forgot about him, or to name him as a favourite character. Of course.
Fontan is an easy read in German, very limpid, not dated at all. Some expressions are not used anymore but else he isn’t much different from today’s writers. He aged far better than others.
The actual translation of “Das ist ein zu weites Feld” is “That is too vast a subject”. Mustn’t blame the translators for the transmutations in my brain.
It seems I have this book on my shelf! Hmmm…..
I’ve posted my thoughts on your questions on my blog:
http://margheallaraleim.wordpress.com/2011/11/05/effi-briest-readalong-week-1-chapters-1-15/
Interesting to compare with yours! We share a love of Rollo…
It is amazing that you are reading ‘Effi Briest’ for the fifth time, Lizzy! Congratulations! I am hoping to read it for the first time, but because I am just starting I will be able to join only on week 2. I will comment on your post after I finish the first 15 chapters. Happy Reading!
Thanks for putting this book out on the interweb, Lizzy – I’m really enjoying it 🙂 My reaction was similar to yours, except for the parents, where I was more sympathetic towards them. My post is here: http://andrewblackman.net/2011/11/2097/
I’m reading the Kindle edition. Some nasty typos.
“Das ist ein…” is translated “too wide a field” and I imagine Effi’s father mopping his brow.
I am reading a lovely handbag-sized German edition from Koenemann, which has been on my bookshelf for years (where did it even come from? I have no idea…)
It’s funny how first sentences can colour your whole view of a book: I don’t know what the translation is like, but the first sentence in German is horribly convoluted and 9 lines long. Every time I’ve picked this novel up previously I have looked at the first page and gone “hmm. Maybe not right now.” But I’m so glad I’ve persevered, it does get better very quickly, and is much easier to read than I was expecting.
The most striking thing about the first part to me is Effi’s sense of fatalism about the whole arrangement. She doesn’t seem to worry about the consequences of marrying a man so much older than her, she just goes along with the plan. It’s not striking because it’s unlikely: quite the opposite, it resonated with me because that’s exactly what 17-year-olds are like – incredibly suggestible, but also with an invincibility complex. Class A drugs? Drink-driving? Ill-advised marriage? Go on then, why not? I’m sure it’ll be fine…
Interesting remark, Ruth. I like Effi a lot, she moves me but I couldn’t imagine a heroine more different from myself, now or when I was 17. It did strike me as well but because it’s the opposite end of how I am or was.
I completely didn’t pay attention to this 9 line long sentence. I always thought Fontane was one of the most accessible writers I know but I just went back to it, and, indeed, you are right.
Hi Lizzie,
I am reading Effi Briest on my Kindle, it is the Penguin translation. I had never heard of Fontane or of Effi Briest before. I know very little about German literature, it was a totally impulsive decision to join in.
I did not have any preconceptions about the novel, but I am enjoying it immensely.
Effi is naive, impulsive, but also ambitious. I am not totally sure what motivates Effi. She agreed to her engagement to Innstetten very easily, this suggests to me that she is loyal to her parents, not particularly stubborn and opportunistic.
The motivation of Innstetten is fascinating, why would he want to marry the daughter of his first love? The match seems calculated but appears to satisfy the motivation of both Effi and Innstetten. Effi marries a baron who is a successful civil servant and handsome as a bonus. Innstetten marries a very young version of the woman who got away.
Effi’s parents come across as tolerant and indulgent of their daughter, which is why their decision to match Effi with Innstetten appears slightly bizarre. However, they are perhaps acting entirely in Effi’s best interests by matching her to a successful man.
I warmed to the character of Roswitha, and her colourful past (I hope this is before the end of chapter 15!).
The first six chapters of the book are particularly light though as Effi’s honeymoon progresses and she becomes increasingly fatigued by the number of art collections she has seen, the tone of the book calms and then grinds to a wintery, eerie halt as Effi arrives in Kessin.
By the end of Chapter 15, Effie appears to be turning from a naive girl into a more rounded person, unavoidably so since she gives birth to a child when she is only just an adult herself.
Fontane was unknown to me although ‘Effi Briest’ was on an old list of novels about late 19th century middle class life in Europe just before WW1 brings it all crashing.
I’ve read the novel on Kindle, then bought a copy listed as a Create Space edition (have no idea what that is). The hard copy appears to be the same as the Kindle – weird words that probably did not scan correctly.
Effi sets the story’s premise when Hertha asks her, “Is he really the right man?” And Effi responds. “Certainly he is the right man…(A)ny man is the right one. Of course he must be a nobleman, have a position and be handsome.” That is her parents’ philosophy, Effi’s training and society’s expectation.
Dagobert doesn’t have much space in the novel but he seems to be more of a lateral thinker than the other characters. I liked him and, of course, the dog.
I hoped Effi’s sarcasm would help her cope with the dreaded ennui; when her father admires the moderation of Innstetten’s letter to Effi, she concurs that, yes, it is moderation and I’m imagining Effi’s eye roll. Crampas comments that “Variety is the spice of life, a truth which , to be sure, every happy marriage seems to controvert.” Effi retorts, “If there are any happy marriages, mine excepted,… .” She then reaches for Innstetten and maybe another eye roll. Effi was bored when she was on the swings or embroidering, marriage didn’t change it much ( well, don’t forget the shopping, always a girl’s best friend). Life is so predictable, Effi can’t even dream about changing much
Finally got mine up. I’ll be catching up soon!
http://www.1morechapter.com/2011/11/05/effi-briest-read-a-long-week-1/