We’ve been reading together for about 4 years and so are well past the getting to know you, being polite stage. So last Monday I was beginning to wonder whether I’d been sent to Coventry. No-one was speaking . They just kept staring at me. Eventually tongues unlocked and the novel was categorically pilloried as the worst book we’ve ever read. Decried also for peddling soft porn off the back of 9/11. We were definitely not amused and the meeting was over in 20 minutes. Our one consolation; sometimes you have to read the rubbish, to appreciate the good stuff. Rating: ![]()
It wasn’t all bad. There were some decent (both senses of the word implied) scenes. But it is a sign of my general malaise that I can only muster up the energy to post this non-review. I shall save myself time by pointing to someone else’s effort. I agree with every word written here.
The front cover blurb predicts that “of all the 9/11 books this is possibly the only one that will pass the test of time”. Yes, well we’ll certainly remember it – unfortunately for all the wrong reasons.
EDIT: I wasn’t going to name it but it appears that not everyone can see the dustjacket on the right. I have just non-reviewed Jay McInerney’s The Good Life.



































Der Struwwelpeter auf Englisch - Translated by Mark Twain



















Mystic Pig - Richard Katrovas

























The Latin American Challenge

1. The Blue Fox


Well, Lizzy, at least everyone was in agreement! But, that does make for a boring book discussion, doesn’t it? I won’t be reading that book.
So what book did you all read and discuss? Obviously I need to scratch it if it is on my wishlist.
Debbie
I couldn’t bring myself to name it but I have shown the dust jacket next to the final paragraph. Is the picture not showing?
That’s really bad, but I guess you all kind of bonded over a bad experience with a book. Did you choose it? Is that why you felt like you’d been sent to Coventry?
I hate it that Jay McInerney laid an egg with this one…I really enjoyed Bright Lights, Big City when I read it about 20 years ago.
It was a communal pick so I had no personal guilt complex.
Being sent to Coventry means noone was speaking to me – a painful experience when trying to lead a book group discussion.
BTW I must go look up the origin of that saying.
That’s always funny when that happens in book clubs. We had that once or twice. But it does leave you with not so very much to say.
Yikes! Sounds like a horrible book. Sounds like someone using 9/11 to make a buck. I hadn’t heard of this book, but I’ll know to steer away from it if I do. How did your book group come to pick that one?
And I agree with every word written here!
thekoolaidmom, I don’t think it’s fair to say McInerney used 9/11 to make a buck. I’m quite sure his intentions were honourable. It’s just that, in my experience, while he’s very good at humour (Story of My Life, Model Behaviour), he’s not so hot at more straight-faced fiction (the terrible Ransom or the so-so Brightness Falls, to which The Good Life was a sequel).
I’m sad I can’t remember the soft porn though as I haven’t held on to my copy!
Cynicism reigned with regard to McInerney’s intentions at our discussion and that harshness may well stem from not having read anything previous. Not that we’re in any hurry to sample further from his menu.
Though I would like to get my mitts on his essays on wine. The caustic wit of the quotes at amazon.com from his Bacchus & Me: Adventures in the Wine Cellar appeal greatly. Unfortunately the book doesn’t seem to be available in the UK.
Oh, well, I wasn’t planning on reading it anyway, because I can’t stand McInerney anyway. “Brightness Falls” was awful!
I remember enjoying this piece by McInerney which was published in the Guardian four days after September 11, 2001. In it he mentions that he is writing a New York novel: presumably The Good Life.
Lizzy, his wine book is available in the UK under a different title.
Mr Self, you are a marvel! I shall report back on the wine book in due course …..